Jury Awards US $833M+ in One of the Largest Trade Secret Verdicts in U.S. History
Kobre & Kim won a US $604.9 million jury verdict — later exceeding US $833 million — for renewable fuels innovator Propel Fuels against oil major Phillips 66.
Following a terminated acquisition by Phillips 66, Kobre & Kim secured a US $604.9 million jury verdict on behalf of Propel Fuels after a five-week trial in the Superior Court of California. The verdict was the most significant trade secret verdict of the previous three years and the fifth-largest verdict of any kind in 2024.
The jury also found Phillips 66’s misconduct willful and malicious, entitling Propel to US $195 million in additional exemplary damages. A subsequent order issued on July 30, 2025 brought the total award to more than US $833 million, with the possibility of an additional award of attorneys’ fees and costs.
“Phillips 66 Hit With $604.9 Million U.S. Verdict in Fuel Trade-Secrets Case”
Reuters
“Michael Ng and Daniel Zaheer of Kobre & Kim represented renewable fuels company Propel against Phillips 66 Co. alongside colleagues in a month-long trial in California state court. Ng argued at closings that a juror question elicited a “confession” from a Phillips executive admitting to liability and trade secret misappropriation.”
Law.com
“Daniel Zaheer of Kobre & Kim told Judge Michael Markman in Alameda County Superior Court that an exemplary-damages award of two times the jury’s unjust-enrichment award was called for because Phillips’ behavior was allegedly on the “high end” of the reprehensibility scale under California’s Uniform Trade Secrets Act.”
Law360
“In closing arguments at the trial, lawyers for Propel Fuels argued that after the theft of its intellectual property, Phillips went from being a “lagger” to “leader” in the multibillion-dollar California renewable fuel market.”
Bloomberg